If this is the real end – 17
Clack, the
sound of something being torn to pieces rang out.
I thought it sounded almost as if
something was severed with scissors.
I quickly tried to search for the
source of that sound, but the black feathers were filling all my vision, plunging
me into the darkness and I couldn’t see anything. I no longer knew whether my
eyes were closed or opened.
I was about to raise my voice, but a
gentle voice held me back. A voice that seemed to be singing, that seemed to be
whispering.
“That child is my precious, very
precious princess, Ilya.”
Or maybe it was a voice full of
solemnity, as if it was warning me.
I didn’t need to confirm it to know
it was mother’s voice. At that time, I was looking at mother’s face reflected
in the mirror, and she was also gazing at me.
Yet I could not remember her
expression clearly.
Was she laughing? Was she sad? Or
did she have the same expression full of love as usual?
“Mother.”
This time, I heard an anxious voice
like that of a child. A heartrending and sad voice, that made you want to
unconsciously stretch out your hands to hug the child.
In the middle of this pure darkness,
a small hand was extended. As if it was looking for something, or was saying
goodbye to someone, it moved from left to right.
I was certain it was only my
imagination that made it look like it was struggling, but the fact it gave me
the feeling that it was drowning wasn’t necessarily a false impression.
I prayed for someone to grasp that
hand. Because it was the only thing I could do.
Please, may someone seize the small hand of that pitiful child.
“… … It is not poison.”
What? Just now, what did you say? I
couldn’t quite hear it.
Bam, Bam. A
sound echoed, as if a fist was hitting hard on a desk.
I was driven by the urge to put my
hand on my ears to block this sound, but I noticed it was a noise that came
from inside me.
Matching the systematic echoes of
that sound, my body was shaking. I realized it was the pulsebeats of my heart.
If it continued like this, my heart would cease to function.
That’s what I thought, yet I could
only helplessly endure that cramping pain.
When I opened my lips to gasp some
air, the sound of gulping down saliva resounded.
“So, she won’t die. That’s what
worried you, right?”
I could see mother’s back as she had
stepped up from the dresser.
The noise I made by catching my
breath and gasping in surprise was absorbed by the carpet.
Reflected in the mirror, were the
silhouettes of mother and I as I gazed at her back.
I remembered this shaken gaze.
Uneasy, lonely, sad.
Even though it was my own face, it
felt like looking at the face of a stranger.
I have seen this scene. At that time,
I was looking at mother across the mirror.
It looked similar, but it also
didn’t. Yet, it certainly looked alike. That’s the feeling I got.
That’s why I noticed it. Pulling the
drawer just a little bit, inserting her fingers in the narrow gap, she took out
“something.”
Only by watching the same scene for
a second time could I understand how important those trivial gestures were.
My heart, which has been beating
strongly since a while ago, made an even louder noise. My vision which
continued to shake irregularly regained its stillness, the sensation of my feet
stepping on the carpet came back.
The breaths I was exhaling were
making the air shake, I actually felt that I was existing now and here.
… … Time had... turned back.
I didn’t have any evidence to make
me think so. It could also be a long dream, but I understood with certainty it
wasn’t the case.
Because after all, I had experienced
this sensation any number of times. Each time I went back to the past in the
blink of an eye, my body kept its five senses.
It might exactly be the same feeling
as when a baby is taken out of its mother’s womb. Even though I should not
remember this sensation, I thought so.
Despite the lack of wind, I noticed
the air touching my skin. My blurred vision was cleared up of all shadows, and
as if my face got out of the water, my hearing returned suddenly.
“Since she started attending school,
that child became energetic. Yes, a lot livelier than before.”
It was a sentence I remembered
hearing. It was justified. Because I had heard it once “before.”
Her hairstyle and attire, and even
her standing posture that I couldn’t forget, were etched in my memory and
wouldn’t go away.
At the very moment the setting sun
was about to end its duty, she slit her own neck.
That person I was supposed to have
lost for all eternity, was now standing in front of me. At a distance close
enough for my hands to reach her.
The previous me was in deep thinking
and missed the omen of her ominous words. Having already lost her sanity,
mother was staring at me absentmindedly while her right arm was slightly
stiffened. Her shaking shoulder was the proof. It was probably because she was
preparing to raise above her head the “something” that was tightly grasped in
her right hand.
Now I understood this well, and
that’s exactly why I couldn’t afford to hesitate even for a second.
That ‘something’ seemed to be
floating in the quiet and dim twilight, resembling a white moon. As it
trembled, it reflected the light and tore the night apart.
“Mother.”
In the middle of the darkness, a
young voice called mother.
I couldn’t say if it was a
hallucination or words I said myself.
“But that’s not good, then. That
situation... that child must be hopeless. It mustn’t become like this.”
Those words sounded like a signal.
As if the paralysis of my body was dispelled, my petrified body became free.
Almost throwing myself on her, I
seized mother’s right arm. It was slender to begin with, but there was no
flexibility in it. It felt almost as if I was grasping a bone.
Before I had noticed, she became so
thin.
The one who immediately let out a
groan, was it me, or mother?
Anyway, I succeeded in preventing
mother from slitting her own neck with her right hand. I bet she never expected
me to do that. Unexpectedly, I could easily restrain her arm.
… … Even though she had carried out
such a gruesome death.
To think I could prevent it so
easily.
“… Mother.” I reflexively called
her, but I didn’t know what to say after that.
We collapsed on the carpet, our
bodies entangled as I held her thin body in my arms.
A knife fell out of mother stretched
out hand. It rolled on the ground. With my arm I swept it away, throwing it in
a distant place that mother’s hand couldn’t reach.
Then I straddled mother’s body and
restrained her. She did resist a bit, but not to the point of struggling
violently, and before long I knew mother was drained of her strength.
Hugging this body very, very
strongly, some sobbing leaked out of my mouth and I bit on my lips.
Even though I could stop her so
easily, so quickly, so uneventfully.
At that time, my mother had died.
“Why… Why did you…?”
My shaking throat couldn’t inhale
air well and I ended up sobbing. I wept like a young child.
Even if I didn’t want to cry like that,
I couldn’t suppress it.
“Why,” did you die, I almost asked, despite the fact the mother who was
here now was alive, was breathing.
“It’s you... who ask that?”
I was questioned by a voice so cold
you wouldn’t imagine it belonged to a person who tried to kill herself.
When my hands loosened
unconsciously, under me, mother twisted her body and repeated in an incoherent
mutter, “… It’s you… who ask that…?”
We stared at each other at
point-blank range, close enough for our cheeks to touch.
“You made Silvia leave this house.”
“… What?”
I failed to ask her what on earth she
meant. The words wouldn’t come out well.
“You tempted her to do so. I never
forgot the day you mustered all your strength in this fervent speech, saying it
was for Silvia’s sake. Even “that” husband was moved by it. Although his heart
could not be moved by anyone else, because you had insisted so much, he allowed
Silvia to attend school. But you knew. How to manipulate him at will. … Right,
you incited him. Isn’t that right?”
Mother didn’t give me any answer to
my question “why did you die?” Naturally. Because she didn’t die. It was a good
thing. …
… No, it should have been a good
thing, but an uneasiness I couldn’t shake away blocked my throat.
In all those lives I had repeated
again and again and again, there hadn’t been even one that had gone like I had
planned.
The more I wished for something, the
more I strayed from my path, bent back and forth, then failed.
Therefore, the corrections I wanted
to make never once came true.
However, now, I had fulfilled my
desire to save mother. I had changed the “past” according to my wish.
For the first time, it seemed like I
had accomplished something.
“You truly... did well, didn’t you?”
If you only cut off these words, you
would likely misinterpret them as a praise.
But the emotion floating in those
verdant green eyes, was blame.
Did I do something wrong again?
“My husband … loves Silvia. No, he
loves her mother. The princess… So, he always obeys that person’s wishes.”
But when she blinked her eyes once,
an intoxicated expression appeared in them.
Just like father who loved the
foreign princess, mother also adored her master.
Even if she ended up abandoning her
hometown for that person’s sake, mother might still consider herself as the
princess’s maid.
“Silvia said she wanted to go to
school, mother. That’s why I…”
“No, no, it’s not true. Because that
child had given up. She had given up leaving this mansion.”
A dark shadow was casted in those
green eyes that were looking up at me.
I once heard mother’s friend praise
those eyes oozing with light for being like green leaves basking in the morning
dew.
Mother was not called “the flower of
high-society”, but even if she stood side by side with the person holding this title,
you wouldn’t think she was inferior.
It’s not that she was excelling at
something. But she was a special person.
And that person’s eyes had become
stagnant and dark, cloudy and polluted.
… … I... until now... have felt that I was already dead.
I remembered the words I heard my
little sister say in one of my lives. As her gaze was clouded by a shadow, she
had muttered them, looking like she would erupt in a cry at any moment.
Because of her frailness, she wasn’t
allowed to do anything. The only activity she could do at best was taking a
daily walk.
I vividly remembered her smiling
silhouette when she said she was “living” like everyone wished, but she
couldn’t do anything except breathing.
“… Did you know? That Silvia was
thinking like that. She was living, having given up everything. … Did you lock
her up while knowing this?”
Each time my words left my mouth, my
throat contracted and I started to suffocate.
It felt like someone was attacking
me, strangling me.
With her back still leaning on the
floor, mother tilted her neck in deep curiosity, like a lost child, and looked
at me with innocent eyes.
“Well, isn’t it safer like this?”
That’s the only way to protect that child, isn’t it? She whispered as if telling a
secret.
“I have made a vow. To protect that
child to the end. We promised to her highness, to take care of her more than of
our child.”
No longer able to reply anymore, I
continued to look at mother who appeared to have lost her mind. Not minding my
emotions at all, she was even smiling, telling me, “because that child was a genuine princess.”
“… And despite that, you put drugs
in her tea?”
“Because that’s the only thing I
could do. To keep that child in the mansion.”
“Then… it was all for the sake of
preventing Silvia from going outside…?”
Just for a reason like this, my
little sister had to drink such a thing?
“To begin with, Silvia was a child
that shouldn’t go outside. It’s true that her body is frail and it’s a good
excuse.”
“Mother, but, Silvia is… Silvia
wants to become healthy…. She said she envied...”
… healthy people. I couldn’t finish my sentence.
My vision was blurring, my voice wouldn’t
come out. My little sister lived on the border between life and death.
I wondered, when was it again when
she was affected by an illness and lost her life?
I only went once to visit her as she
was on the verge of death, and that child, who had withered away to the point
of having thin arms like dead branches, had whispered, “I’m jealous of you, big sister. I wish I had been healthier.”
I didn’t reply, and that child also might
not have been expecting anything from me. It was surely just a soliloquy.
Then why, did it remain in my memory
so clearly?
“But I love that child. I cherish
her very, very carefully.”
“… Carefully?”
“Yes. That child was always... my
lovely princess. She is my one and only precious daughter in this world. That’s
why... I’m sorry Ilya.”
“D-don’t say it, mother. Please.”
“That’s why... I have never……”
Ah, wait. I didn’t want to hear the
rest.
My lips, which had dried up
completely, exhaled an arid breath.
I couldn’t even tell if I had spoken
up those words or not, but mother thin fingers gently stroked my cheek. The
warmth I couldn’t help but desire in my childhood was there, here and now.
Yet, it felt like gravels of sand
were thrown into the depths of my heart. I couldn’t help but feel a dull pain.
“D-don’t say it, mother. Please.”
“That’s why... I have never……”
I promptly covered her soft lips
with the palm of my hands.
Sill, her muffled voice was
resisting, trying to say some words.
That’s why I pressed down that
person’s face with even more strength.
Everything I had believed in, was
gone.
“Do not say it, mother, don’t. Don’t
say it, d-don’t say… …”
That you don’t love me, even if it’s
a lie, don’t say it.
Don’t say you didn’t love me even
once.
I didn’t want to know that, in this
world, no one had ever loved me.
No, in truth, I already knew since
long ago, but still, I wanted to pretend I didn’t.
“My... mother. My, and mine only...
mother.”
That’s right.
In reality, she should have been my mother and
mine alone.
Until the day, until the moment
Silvia was born into this world.
“Once is fine, it’s fine even only
once, so lie. Tell me… that you love me.”
I felt mother’s breath on my palms
and heard her groaning voice.
I wanted to hear these words too,
but I couldn’t move from that spot, nor could I remove my hands. My only
thought was that I had to block her words.
The voice that rejected me sounded
like a signal announcing the end of the world.
“Mother, mother... do you... love
me… …?”
In the green eyes, which were
wide-opened, I could see the face of a child who had broken down in tears.
I saw her ashen hair and her eyes of
the faded color of fallen leaves.
It was a face that looked terribly familiar.
That figure who kept crying was
pitiful, sorrowful, and made my heart ache.
“… … Mother !!!!”
That’s why... someone please... save
that child.
Someone please, save her from that
despair.
Chapter 33 Chapter 35
Please please please, just a lie is enough
ReplyDeleteT-T Sniff,I know right....it's only 3 words! P.s. thanks for the chapter!
DeleteThe mother is not that kind...
DeleteCliff everywhere. Even Nocta's thoughts have cliff. Thanks for the chapter.
ReplyDeleteMwawawawawawa
DeleteMy god.. ..(꒦ິ-꒦ີ)
ReplyDeleteHow cruel.
This obsessive mania that husband and wife have over the little sister.. .
My heart breaks for Ilya...
Let's continue to suffer together!
DeleteOH FOR GOD SAKE JUST BECAME YANDERE ALREADY!!!
ReplyDeleteyou're already halfway, and it's better for your health
She is on a threshold between turning Yandere and going completely crazy.
Deletefunny how she was poisoning Silvia because of love but always neglecting and not caring for Ilya because she was tired? the mother feelings doesn't make sense, if anything she should be loathing Silvia, not caring and loving her.
ReplyDeleteI still don't understand why the mother doesn't like Ilya
Mah, it's hard to understand what yandere people think. And there are women who don't feel love for their child, so...
DeleteReadinh this in the goddamn airport. Waiting for my people and desperately trying not to cry goddamnit. I knew this novel makes my cry every chapter and I still do thiiiiss.
ReplyDeleteThnks for the chapter!
Mwawawa you are welcome!
DeleteAh, so I was almost right about the poison being intended to keep Silvia at home, I just terribly underestimated her mother's yandere obsession towards Silvia. I assumed it was her father who was obsessed and her mother was just doing her job, but no, her father actually was willing to allow Silvia some freedom, even if it took some persuasion. Her mother, in the other hand... I wonder if she's being affected by the same strange corrective force that Soleil is trapped by?
ReplyDeleteI'm not quite sure what's happening here, though - is it a vision Crow is giving her, of what could have happened had she managed to save her mother? Or is it a memory of when this happened before, in a previous life, when she was able to save her mother, but was faced with such an awful truth that she buried the memory away? So even though she was faced with the same situation, she wasn't able to act - or she didn't act, so she wouldn't have to hear those words again? The sound of something being cut, the fact that she feels as if she's looking at her mother through a mirror, and the way she describes herself from the outside, all make me think that this is some kind of vision or dream, rather than something she's literally doing at this moment, but it's hard to say.
Thanks for the chapter. I almost don't believe you that the next few chapters are encouraging, lol. This story is so relentlessly bleak, I have no idea why I love it so much.
I always have to remind me that this is supposed to be an otome game (?) so my guess would be that she maybe reached some checkpoint? If that were to be the truth that still leaves many questions open like, did Crow know about that? Why has she never reached it before? Is the save point triggered by some sort of "successful" development? What were to happen if she ever reaches the final end? Start anew?
DeleteAnd those forces are the hardest to judge anyway! Even during Soleil's POV chapter it becomes harder and harder to distinguish what is caused by the force and what by Soleil's own will as time moves on. At the end it looks like it was solely his will but no one can say what can happen to a person controlled his entire life
In visual novels sometimes you have to trigger an event to open a new path in a past point, or to reach an ending to open a new route or ending.
DeleteAs for this restart, I wonder if it's Crow's doing. He can use some sort of magic after all. Turn into a crow, into several human forms, inter locked room. Maybe the black feathers are a sign of his magic manifesting and it's him who helps Ilya turn time back. But we won't know the answer anytime soon
DeleteWhat if everything is done by Crow as some sort of weird experiment? As far as we know, he likes to observe and for some reason is fixated on Ilya. So perhaps he is trying to prove something... O_O
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteOtome game corrective force is scary.
DeleteMother after her suicide seem freed of the force like Soleil was. But now that she is alive she may still be controlled by it.
I like to mention, rather question, the use of "laugher" is weird, shouldn't it be laughter instead?
ReplyDeleteOh, you're right, you'r right. I'll correct it! Thanks!
DeleteThis chapter is so sad. Close to those pregnancy chapters in the flashback.
ReplyDeleteI knew the mother tried to keep Silvia at place but never did I realize she was that much yandere over her! How can she even do that? How can she treat Ilya as such? That time Ilya said that her mother wasn't heartless must have been her own wish fulfillment! That woman is better of dead! Oh, take the father and make it two please!
I knew some restart was coming but not like that. Did Ilya reach some sort of check/save point? Why now and not previously? Or was it Crows doing? I don't think he has the power to return time so did he maybe kill her so that she can go back in time?
I hope things get better. With this much rustling in the bushes even that oblivious Silvia can't ignore/not see it anymore and I think that she has to be key for Ilya to ever have a chance for a good future. She has to have Silvia on her side but at the same time that makes her vulnerable at the same time.
"That’s why, someone please, save that child.
Someone please, save her from that despair."
These last two sentences... it's like the author is driving a knife in her readers' heart and turning it slowly while smiling.
DeleteI feel we are searching an important point but... I am beginning to think of something... our mc seems to always make mistakes and as narrator the is not credible so... could it be the Made a mistakes? Now come she is the older sister? If the father had a child with the princess before marring the maid... the mother said that Ilya can make her father do what she want... How Come? Could it be that Ilya is the child of the princess? That would explain her "mother" attitude... And the reason why Silvia can't go outsider is becouse she was not supposed to be born... oh well this could be a theory but who knows
ReplyDeleteBut Silvia looks like the princess, same hair and eyes colors, same facial features, so...
DeleteNow I hate that princess as much as Soleil.
ReplyDeleteWe hate her even though she had never appeared directly in the novel. She is quite a good vilain
DeleteTime for wild plot guessing! The Princess is a witch! At least a drug brainwashing witch!
ReplyDeleteWell, if Crow can do magic, others characters can too
DeleteI always feels like this novel gives clues just to confuse its readers and I'm seriously confused right now.
ReplyDeletePerhaps the mother wants Ilya to hate her?
ReplyDeleteI mean, if I was in her shoes (with all the drama and everything) and if there was no other choice, then I would do anything to make my child hate me, that way perhaps she/he could overcome the grief felt over not receiving my love and it also can become a sort of punishment for myself.
The true evil in this story is the egoistical princess. If she was so in love with the father, then she should have married him. Or at least heroically died while trying. But no, she chose to return to her kingdom, for whatever reason, and become queen while leaving an innocent woman behind to be the spouse of her lover because she was jealous he could be happy with another woman.
Really? Like really? What if he wanted to remain a bachelor for the rest of his life?!
I say this is pure... product-of-digestion.
Anyways, afterwards, when everyone had adjusted to their new circumstances, she comes back and is like: "Oh truth be told I have never forgotten you" and then goes and conceive a child. Afterwards she abandons both, to return to her kingdom.
Leaving a mess behind her.
I mean, by then she was already the Queen. If she wanted, she could marry him. Or if she was already married politically to someone, at least she could have tried making something up to take him back. It is not that rare for royalty who had a political marriage to have an affair or too behind closed doors. That way she could have been happy, the father I guess too, and Silvia could grow up in a more healthy way (excluding the daily poison).
And if the queen had no way to return with him, because it was dangerous or whatever, then she should have not conceived Silvia in the first place.
Such an irresponsible and heartless person. Why did she come back?
Arrgh! How exasperating!
…sigh…
I still hate the mother though.
Her circumstances don't change the fact that she was a terrible mother. A self-centered, cruel person in fact.
And Ilya… Ilya is very pitiful.
Growing up while feeling unloved is terrible. But she needs to learn how to let go. That way, maybe, she can achieve a good ending (though my heart is telling me only death awaits...). Also, she needs to try and understand those who are around her. Crow already gave her the clue that she was not the only one suffering, yet even after all those lives, she only strives to make things better without trying to really understand the reasons behind their actions. I mean, after so many lives she should have already gathered plenty of experience, why isn’t she learning from it? To solve a problem, you need to first find the root of it.
Her problem= she dies tragically and no one seems to care.
Solution= She needs to start questioning the reasons behind their apparent indifference and her tragic deaths.
Instead= she obsess with her own pain and tries to find a solution by solving the things she believed she did wrong and brought about her tragic end, without really investigating the reasons behind them.
Truly a tragedy in many levels.
Btw Thanks for your hardwork in translating. ^^
It is a slow moving story but I'm liking it very much. Though those cliffs are certainly terrible and heart wrenching.
Sorry for the long text(I was inspired)... and for the bad English (it is not my native tongue).
It's me who thank you for sharing your thoughts! Reading what you wrote was interesting! Your theory on the mother is plausible, that's a possible behavior, but I still have the feeling she just didn't care at all about Ilya.
DeleteAnd that princess, I don't even want a chapter about her, I don't care for her circumstances, that's how bad my impression of her is
A lie is enough.
ReplyDeleteSo please tell her that you love her.
Please explain to me did ilya go back in time ? Did she die on the funeral??? Or the occuring events right now are reconciling memories that she's imagined she had fixed?
ReplyDeleteOMG this is so heartbreaking. I can't stop reading it while crying. Thank you for the chapter!
ReplyDeleteShe'll finally leave those fuc*ers behind and live with Crow right? RIGHT???
ReplyDeletewe think ilya alone suffer so much in this story,, turns out other characters has their own sad back stories as well. '(
ReplyDeleteid rather her become phsycho , if i were her i would have unalived everyone , id live with crow too coz why not , everyone is nuts here @-@
ReplyDeleteEVERYTHING HURTS BRO THIS CHAPTER LITERALLY HAS ME ON A MF CHOKEHOLD
ReplyDelete